Tragedy of girl's sudden death

A nine-year old girl collapsed and died while at a school swimming lesson moments after completing a width of the pool without armbands or a float for the first time. Jade Johnstone, a Year 4 pupil at Lyncrest Primary School, Duston, Northampton, had gone to the Duston School with her classmates or a swimming lesson on the morning of Monday January 28, 2008.

The youngster, from Duston Road, Northampton, had been a non-swimmer when she started classes in September 2007 and was determined to complete a width of the pool unaided as part of a school certificate.

At an inquest held at Northampton General Hospital yesterday, a statement by teacher Sue Wallace was read out in which she described watching Jade as she swam and then fell ill. She said: โ€œJade was swimming across the pool without armbands. She completed her 10m and was smiling at me. I put both my thumbs up at her and said โ€œWell done, that was brilliant.โ€ I glanced away and she lying back with her legs towards me. I said: โ€œThis isnโ€™t right, letโ€™s get her out.โ€

School governor Lesley Loveland had also been at the swimming pool when the tragedy happened. In her statement she said: โ€œJade was holding onto the side of the pool. The next thing her head slumped back and she let go of the side. I said โ€˜Are you alright?,โ€ her eyes rolled and I said โ€œSheโ€™s not alright.โ€ Jade was pulled from the pool. Paramedics arrived on scene but were unable to resuscitate her.

Dr Charles Padfield, a consultant in foetal and neonatal pathology at the Queenโ€™s Medical Centre, carried out the post mortem on Jade. He said: โ€œI am convinced she didnโ€™t drown. โ€œHer heart was normal. At the end of the day I think the most accurate diagnosis, or as near as we could get, is sudden cardiac death syndrome which a morphologically normal heart. There was no ongoing disease in her other organs that could have accounted for any death like this.

Addressing Jadeโ€™s parents, John and Jan, Dr Padfield added: โ€œMagnificently, you donated for research in teaching. thank you very much.

Recording a verdict of death by natural causes, which were heart-related, deputy coroner Rodney Haig said: โ€œItโ€™s one of those things that just happens occasionally for no explicable reason. I give you my sympathies.

A memorial day was held in August, which raised about ยฃ2,000 for Cardiac Risk in the Young, and an outdoor stage was installed at Lyncrest Primary School by Jadeโ€™s classmates.